- Home
- >
- Software Development
- >
- All About ‘Bank Python,’ a Finance-Specific Language Fork – InApps Technology 2022
All About ‘Bank Python,’ a Finance-Specific Language Fork – InApps Technology is an article under the topic Software Development Many of you are most interested in today !! Today, let’s InApps.net learn All About ‘Bank Python,’ a Finance-Specific Language Fork – InApps Technology in today’s post !
Read more about All About ‘Bank Python,’ a Finance-Specific Language Fork – InApps Technology at Wikipedia
You can find content about All About ‘Bank Python,’ a Finance-Specific Language Fork – InApps Technology from the Wikipedia website
In November, London-based software engineer Cal Paterson published a fascinating “oral history of Bank Python,” describing it as “The strange world of Python, as used by big investment banks … effectively proprietary forks of the entire Python ecosystem.”
In an email interview with InApps Technology, Paterson told me he’s worked at more than one institution using its own flavor of Bank Python — and the “strong similarities” suggest IT workers carried the banner of its basic ideology when they moved from one investment bank to another.
“If you know a certain important function existed at a previous bank in a certain file, it probably exists in the same file in your current bank,” he said.
His own work history includes writing Python in proprietary in-house environments at JP Morgan (Athena) and Bank of America Merill Lynch (Quartz), as well as a four-month gig as a Python developer at Citibank. (Although Paterson also adds that even within the investment banking industry, “some banks have it and some do not.”)
To avoid revealing employer-specific details, his blog post just presented a fictional amalgamation of what he’s seen throughout his career. But it still offers a great chance to explore an exotic fork of an entire programming language, which is almost completely unknown to the general public.
Underscoring the intrigue in his essay, Paterson writes that “foreign systems, like foreign countries, can be mind-expanding when experienced firsthand.”
No Filesystems, Just a Big Database of Objects
The first big surprise: Bank Python doesn’t have access to a filesystem! But it also doesn’t seem to need one, since most of what it would operate on already exists in a massive database of objects, representing things like trade and market data. These objects represent everything from simple bonds to more complex derivative instruments.
“If some bad news about a company is published and a credit agency downgrades their credit rating, then someone in bonds will update the relevant Bond object,” Paterson’s essay explained.
And this instantly propagates to any other calculations that include the value of that bond object — just as simple as changing a cell’s value in an Excel spreadsheet automatically causes any formulas using that cell to update its own value. (This also allows the implementation of handy additional features like “time-traveling” through your data to see its values in the past or future.)
An anthropologist might argue this structure holds clues to the culture of investment banks. Interestingly, Paterson described this stack in his essay as “heavily influenced by the technological path dependency of the financial sector, which is another way of saying: there is a lot of MS Excel.”
Through the years, he acknowledged in his essay, many have had logical business reasons for a company-wide switch to Kubernetes, microservices and a service mesh. But weaning reluctant users off their familiar Microsoft spreadsheet “takes away that basic agency of those Excel users, who no longer understand the business process they run and now have to negotiate with ludicrous technology dweebs for each software change.”
He continued, “Using simple Python functions, in a source-controlled system, is a better middle ground than the modern-day equivalent of Java 2 Enterprise Edition.
“Financiers are able to learn Python, and while they may never be amazing at it they can contribute to a much higher level and even make their own changes and get them deployed.”
So Bank Python programs first just open a connection to that database of objects — and then away they go. But it’s even crazier than that, since even your application’s main source code gets stored in that database, where it’s run by a single jobs-processing “runner.”
In his essay, Paterson compared it to something like Jenkins or systemd — and note that this setup has several advantages. “It can restart your software if it crashes and sends out alerts if it keeps crashing. It stores logs. It understands dependencies between jobs (much like systemd does) so if the job that generates the data your job needs fails, your job doesn’t even try starting up but instead fires more alerts.”
But most importantly, it lets you run code in a major security-conscious institution just by creating a very simple initialization file. “This is a big deal because negotiating anything in large bank is an exercise in frustration: lead times on hardware can be measured in months,” Paterson wrote. “Getting people to agree with you takes, of course, much longer than that.”
Customized Python, ‘Invented’ In-House
Bank Python implementations also seem to be using their own proprietary data structure for tables, offering faster access to medium-sized datasets (while storing them more efficiently in memory).
“Some implementations are lumps of C++ (not atypical of financial software) and some are thin veneers over sqlite3,” Paterson said. (His friend Salim Fadhley, a London-based developer, has even released an (all-Python) version of the table data structure called eztable.)
Paterson concludes that while most programming has a code-first approach, Bank Python would be characterized as data-first. While it’s ostensibly object-oriented, “you group the data into tables and then the code lives separately.”
Needless to say, Bank Python inevitably ends up getting its own internal integrated development environment (IDE) to handle all of its unique configuration quirks, and it even has its own unique version-control system for code. Paterson acknowledged the uncharitable assessment that it’s all just a grand exercise in distrusting anything that originated outside the company (known in the programming field as the fearful “Not Invented Here” syndrome).
The biggest downside made be for the developers who work there, since every year you spend in your employer’s bespoke monoculture, “the skills you need to interact with normal software atrophy.” Just one example: “When everything is in the same repository and all code is just an import away, software packaging just does not come up.”
Of course, after years of working at banks, Paterson also experienced a more personal problem: “existential ennui arising from prolonged exposure to Windows 7 and MS Outlook 2010.”
Developers Share ‘Bank Python’ Tales
Paterson’s blog post captured the interest of developers on social media, garnering 546 upvotes in Reddit’s programming forum, and another 864 upvotes on Hacker News. “Having worked in an investment bank before this brought some flashbacks,” admitted one Hacker News commenter.
“Honestly, this sounds a lot less insane than a lot of ‘conventional’ stacks,” another reader commented.
regarding the bank python article: I’ve worked on systems which were almost equally “locked in” and had some (seemingly) weird choices inside BUT also amazing, creative, incredibly useful/usable ideas I’d do again in a heartbeat – sometimes in horrible, sometimes in good code.
— Su-Shee (@[email protected]) (@sheeshee) November 14, 2021
But it’s a glimpse into an alternate universe where entire software systems are ultimately home-brewed in-house. One Hacker News comment came from Sean Hunter, a former vice president on the Goldman Sachs strategist (or “strats”) team, who posted that he’d been the one who’d introduced Python there around 2002 to 2003.
And Hunter shared some more memories with the eFinancialCareers site, remembering how over his next nine years at Goldman Sachs they’d even created an ahead-of-its-time DevOps environment deploying code updates with a CI/CD pipeline — written in Perl.
“At that time it was 20 million lines of C++ and 10 million lines of Java and we’d push it out to all our machines worldwide,” Hunter said. He believes that, at the time, there was nothing like it anywhere else in the world.
And there was also a cloud-like internal computing grid where calculations were spread across different servers. (In a later comment, Hunter recalled 667 different developers committing in just one two-week cycle.) “Everything we did was top secret and no one outside would ever know about it,” he told eFinancial Carers about his time at Goldman Sachs. “Banks build huge amounts of things for specific use cases that don’t exist yet and then the world catches up.”
Respect for ‘Bank Python’ Contributors
Paterson enjoyed Hunter’s comments on Hacker News, and said he also heard from people who work outside of the finance industry saying they liked the idea of Bank Python. “I think there are a number of ‘k8s dissidents’ who dislike the direction that making software has gone in.”
He also suggested that, today, the company Beacon is essentially marketing “a white-label version of Bank Python.”
But underneath his reaction seems to be a true appreciation for all the care and effort that went into building an entire Bank Python ecosystem.
Today Python’s core team has now grown and become more professionalized/less volunteer — but Paterson estimates that, in 2010, a large bank that forked the Python ecosystem (including the interpreter) could’ve ultimately been deploying more manhours than Python’s original, smaller, all-volunteer core team.
In our interview, Paterson described the system as “brilliant,” and told me he wished he could still use it.
Source: InApps.net
List of Keywords users find our article on Google:
python jobs |
excel grand forks |
python all |
veneers el segundo ca |
python fork |
all python |
inhouse bank |
efinancial career |
bank of america java developer jobs |
t-mobile – closed paterson |
website development company american fork |
t-mobile – closed in paterson |
veneers mission district |
outsourced investment banking representative |
python developer jobs |
memory care paterson |
bank software developer |
custom banners paterson |
lynch syndrome wikipedia |
jp morgan software engineer interview |
weaning wikipedia |
veneers wikipedia |
dweebs global |
fork wikipedia |
goldman sachs bank usa cd rates |
appsmith |
bank of america software developer jobs |
weaning fork |
python foreach |
white label social media software |
efinancialcareers jobs |
fork saigon ho chi minh city |
ho chi minh veneers |
bank of america python |
open banking and the finance stack of the future |
python jobs london |
python developer london |
banner service paterson |
python a |
finance website templates |
python runner |
excel keeps crashing |
middle python developer |
efinancialcareers app |
efinancialcareers london |
bank of america k8s |
efinancialcareers review |
finance python jobs |
bank of america ci/cd |
python finance jobs |
fork python |
java developers london outsource |
citibank software engineer |
amazon veneers |
jenkins job builder |
goldman sachs ux |
hacker news jobs |
python assessment linkedin |
what values would characterize a conscious corporate culture? |
linkedin python assessment |
work from home python jobs |
bank of america qa jobs |
social media marketing agency ho chi minh |
social media marketing company american fork |
citibank tech stack |
learn python reddit |
hire banking ui designers |
ats grid |
c++ filesystem path |
python recruitment |
python job runner |
athena stack review |
bank of america developer jobs |
wawa citi |
jp morgan code for good |
bank of america backend development |
better-sqlite3 |
k8s alert |
custom application development |
“python software house” |
efinancialcareers investment banking |
atypical wikipedia |
efinancialcareers jp morgan |
efinancialcareers news |
efinancial career news |
efinancialcareers usa |
python to golang |
white label saas |
strats goldman sachs |
“efinancialcareers” |
python in investment banking |
the strange house – wikipedia |
python wikipedia |
efinancialcareers |
reddit learnpython |
hcmc forum |
python language wikipedia |
goldman sachs python developer |
goldman sachs strats |
goldman sachs front end developer |
ms banks wikipedia |
eztable |
goldman sachs software engineer |
jp morgan software engineer |
citibank devops |
ats keeps crashing |
bank of america software developer |
citi python |
citibank python |
paterson recruitment |
goldman sachs devops |
lynch syndrome wiki |
fork language |
citibank software development |
citibank wawa |
citibank microservices |
hunter match in banking |
citibank wikipedia |
goldman sachs java developer |
internal mobility goldman sachs |
ui grid cell template |
citibank kubernetes |
citibank software engineering |
hacker news status |
microsoft partner technology strategist |
python for investment banking |
secret veneers trustpilot |
veneers amazon |
goldman recruitment |
goldman sachs data scientist jobs |
hot topic grand forks |
home security systems paterson |
david frame jp morgan |
wiki ennui |
mainsource bank locations |
wawa ratings |
python developer jobs london |
quartz lumps |
excel sheet locked by me |
hire perl developers |
house python code |
linkedin assessment python |
python kubernetes client |
redfox finance |
the fork app |
cloud computing essay |
python developer no experience |
athena tan |
python a* |
quirks jobs |
strats finance |
bank of america el segundo |
citibank offshore banking |
python jobs no experience |
python developer job |
python teams message |
excel for investment banking |
given number is strong or not in python |
lynch and paterson |
ennui protection |
citibank ho chi minh |
investment banking excel |
hacker news search |
athena technology group |
foreach python |
mainsource bank review |
su shee |
technology investment banking interview |
saas instruments |
bank of america business development jobs |
full-time perl developer vacatures |
chi-x jp morgan |
web developer grand forks |
fork c++ |
custom vision python |
e commerce financial model template |
python /a |
systemd restart never |
bank of america data science jobs |
all in python |
kubernetes python client |
python developer |
top tech investment banks |
white label review software |
financial app development company |
python mobile app development |
Let’s create the next big thing together!
Coming together is a beginning. Keeping together is progress. Working together is success.